Publications

 
Home Home
Home Events
Project Members Project Members
Project Lines Project Lines
  Architecture 
                  and Infrastructure Architecture and Infrastructure
  Personal 
                  Journal Personal Journal
  Reflection 
                and Introspection Reflection and Introspection
Publications Publications
Flyer Flyer
 
provided by
sponsored by

character by

last modified:
2006-04-21
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Evaluation of Automatically Designed Mechanisms

By: Anthony Jameson, Christopher Hackl, and Thomas Kleinbauer (2003)

Proceedings of the Bayesian Modeling Applications Workshop at the Nineteenth Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence, Acapulco, Mexico.

Abstract: In their UAI 2002 paper "Complexity of Mechanism Design", Conitzer and Sandholm presented computationally tractable methods for automated mechanism design (AMD): For a given specific preference aggregation problem, such a method generates a nonmanipulable outcome selection mechanism. The present paper examines some of the decisions that need to be made by a designer who is considering the application of AMD in a particular context. Using examples from the application area of rating aggregation, we discuss several potentially desirable properties of mechanisms: symmetry, determinism, familiarity, equity, and robustness. Our example evaluations illustrate that some of these properties can be straightforwardly achieved with the methods of AMD, whereas others may sometimes require the designer to resort instead to standard mechanisms (such as averaging of ratings) that may not fall within the scope of AMD. We conclude that it is advisable, in any particular application setting, to conduct comparative evaluations of potential mechanisms; and that these comparisons should sometimes include hand-crafted mechanisms.

Note: Workshop page: http://www.intel.com/research/events/bayesian/

301 KB

 

BibTeX entry:

@inproceedings{JamesonHK03,
year = {2003},
author = {{Jameson}, Anthony and {Hackl}, Christopher and {Kleinbauer}, Thomas},
title = {Evaluation of Automatically Designed Mechanisms},
booktitle = {Proceedings of the Bayesian Modeling Applications Workshop at the Nineteenth Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
address = {Acapulco, Mexico},
note = {Available from http://dfki.de/~jameson/abs/JamesonHK03.html}}